Jack's Girlfriends in Dawn and Whitney FF

[liss31d]

In your opinion, who was the worst of the women that Dawn's father, Jack dated in Dawn and Whitney Friends Forever? Who would honestly bother you the most?

Is it over-excited patronising Clarisse who offered to take Dawn bra-shopping as it "obviously doesn't fit" and needs a "woman's touch?"

Is it uptight pretentious health freak (yes even bigger than health facist Dawn) Barbara, who was rude to the waitress and called Jack (gasp) Richard!?

Is it prejudiced insensitive Karina who acted repulsed by Whitney, stating that the "scenery" was making her lose her appetite?

Is it sarcastic Kayla who had a snotty equally sarcastic b**ch for a daughter (Alana the Pain)?

Or is it Carol, the one he actually marries, who according to Dawn tries to act like she's still a teenager?

[Lauren]

Karina.

[magentanation]

Yep, definitely Karina. I mean, come on. A grown woman acting that way....shameful.

[aln1982]

I think Karina's behavior was dreadful, uncalled for and absolutely disgusting. But I wanted to do something "different" and voted for Clarisse because I thought she sounded the most annoying as a potential girlfriend. I can't see how anyone would want to be around Karina so don't really consider her a possible future mate for Jack. I think Clarisse could get on someone's nerves really fast but thought the chapter with her was hilarious. Barbara was a big pain, too, though. Kayla's only real fault, I thought, was her daughter, which wasn't exactly her fault (unless it is said that she's the one who raised "Alana the pain-a") and I like Carol. So glad Jack ended up with her because the others were real "winners" ;D

[sotypical42483]

Oh crap. I assumed it was favorite of the women, so I voted for Carol without reading the post. I was shocked Karina was winning. I take back my Carol vote!!! I would vote for Karina as the worst.

[fluffycakes]

^ Ha ha, I almost did that!

Karina was pretty awful, for the obvious reasons, but I really hated Barbara as well. I found her to be so utterly unbeliveable both as a character and as a person Jack go one more than one date with (since family dates come after one on one dates, Jack would've had to liked her enough on their other dates in order to bring Dawn and Jeff along). I voted for Karina, but Barbara is a close second.

[aln1982]

^ I thought it was interesting how Clarissa and Barbara were almost opposites. Thought Barbara was pretty annoying too in her own way. Actually, the fish place sounded pretty good (though for some reason, I'm picturing Long John Silver's and can never imagine Dawn going there) ;D
Sotypical, I would have chosen Carol for my favorite, too I really like her and thought it was funny at the end of Dawn and Whitney FF how Dawn and Jeff wanted her back after complaining about her before.

[sugarmonkey]

I voted for Clarisse just because as aln said, I can't imagine Karina lasting long regardless. Clarisse jumping the gun and talking about helping Dawn buy a new bra and insulting the fit on her current one seemed like red flags of a controlling person. I think in long term relationship Clarisse would turn out to be pushy, controlling, and cover it all up with a happy I-was-just-trying-to-help mask.

[liss31d]

OK so far Karina is the most hated with 3 votes, with Clarisse in 2nd place with 2 votes! Keep voting

[magentanation]

^I don't like Clarisse either. I have a hard time reading her name without it sounding like Hannibal Lechter's voice. ;D

[lyricalangel]

^LOL magentanation : )

[Deleted]

I voted for Karina for the obvious reasons, though I thought that Clarisse was pretty annoying as well. I don't really remember Barbara, though, so I guess I'd have to reread that book. Did she try to make Dawn drink a glass of milk or something like that at a restaurant? Maybe I'm completely off.

Random Shy Girl

[Penny Lane]

I hated them all, including Carol. Why does Jack have to remarry so quickly anyway? Was he seeing Carol before the divorce? I mean, it just seems weird.

Then I think about how Sharon got married first... Ahh bsc dating.

[aln1982]

^ BSC time in general. ;D I love it how they can have so many Christmases, Halloweens, etc. while staying the same age. Reminds me a bit of the movie Christmas Do Over, which I was disappointed that I couldn't find this year as I loved it last year. ;D I wish I could live in that kind of world with second chances for everything like that. ;D

[greer]

Whenever i think of cap'n jack's fun fish fry, i think of the pirate restaurant they go to on full house for tanner family fun night. Ok, maybe i'm the only dork here who owns all seven seasons of full house on dvd

I voted for karina. I just want to know why jack found so many bad women. We all know from the pictures in dawn's portrait that jack is hott. Although i guess he was set up by people, but a lot of these women were pretty terrible.