Favorite portrayal of each sitter?

[CharlotteTJohanssen]

Which actress do you think best fit each sitter? Either in terms of looks or personality? 

1990 Kristy is still my favorite. She has the same personality as her book counterpart and looks. 

2020 Mary Anne, I’m sold on the awkward personality she has. I didn’t like the last episode and her arc in that but aside from that I love her. 

2020 and 1995 Stacey, I like the look of 1995 Stacey but prefer the personality of 2020 Stacey. 

2020 Dawn in terms of personality. I don’t think any of the three actresses are exactly how I picture dawn. 

2020 Claudia by a long shot. She’s so cute! 

1990 Mallory, she’s got the whole awkward part of Mallory down. Plus I think had more lines then any of the other girls, but I could be wrong. 

I dint think we got enough of Jessi in any of the three versions for me to really judge. 

[andrew]

Kristy 1990 by far really good

Stacey 1995 by a bit or 1995 and 2020 tied, both good nicely pretty much the same character (at different stages).

Claudia 1995 best though the others were also good

Dawn 1990 for looks, otherwise 1990 and 1995 tied both similar and both good.

Mary Anne 1995 by a bit or 1990 and 1995 tied both good, pretty much the same character (at different stages)

Mallory 1990 and 1995 tied both similar and both good

Jessi 1990 by a bit though just OK

[cnj]

1995 was the best for all of them for me.

1990 Kristy, Dawn and Mallory were good also.

But especially with Claudia, Mary Anne, Stacey, Jessi as well as the rest of them, the 1995 film was the best in terms of physical appearance, personalities and the solid friendship chemistry between the girls.

The 2020 personalities seem to be great so far also.