Post by sparklymouse on Nov 28, 2017 22:08:36 GMT -5
Stacey was apparently the most popular back in the day. Do you think she would still be if the series was a new thing in 2017? (I think she is ordinary and annoying, so unfortunately probably yes.) I think Dawn could be pushed to the front of the pack since all of her passions are still hot topics in the country. Girls might tune into a "girl power" character like her or Kristy. (I know so many of you hate Dawn, but think beyond how she was written and look at the message that was hidden in there somewhere.) Jessi, I think, could be much more popular now. People crave diversity and characters that are like them/they can relate to.
So, do you think different girls could be more popular now, or would the Disney princesses of the group still be on top?
Probably Claudia (from both not doing so well in school/feeling overshadowed by her sister and being really creatively artistic), she would appeal to a lot of people who felt not the most successful overall but still wanted to shine in something they themselves liked. Kristy might be more popular today as well, most or second most popular (arguably the star, the one who keeps the club together and just contributes the most) especially if she was written a little more as fighting for the club against others rather than being so demanding of the club members.
Dawn would probably necessarily be pretty love her or hate her.
I would imagine that Jessi, Mallory, Mary Anne, Dawn, Logan, Shannon and Claudia would have their own cult-followings, lol. And the most loved would probably be Kristy by adult professionals who would admire her for starting a very successful business at such a young age. And the second would be Stacey because girls tend to want to be considered pretty no matter how they look, lol, and Stacey seems very down-to-earth even though she is an idolized archetype in society.
Post by nancydawes on May 13, 2020 23:05:21 GMT -5
Old post but I could totally see Dawn becoming more popular. She's spreading messages that people care about more today then they did then (not saying that they didn't then but attitudes have shifted). Like more people are vegetarian and caring about the environment more where more girls could relate to her.
I think Stacey will always be popular regardless.
Claudia will probably be a huge favorite too.
Like the poster above me said, the others will have their own cult followings lol.